• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO – Authentic Italian Dining & Exceptional Service in Sarasota, FL

THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO, nestled in a charming historic house in Sarasota, delivers an authentic Italian dining experience. Chef Antonio’s passion shines through in every dish—from the tender lamb chops to flavorful clam fettuccine and savory gnocchi bursting with rich flavors. The warm hospitality, highlighted by personal greetings from the chef and attentive service, creates an intimate, welcoming atmosphere perfect for celebrations or quiet dinners. Combining elegant ambiance with home-cooked quality, this gem stands out as Sarasota’s premier Italian restaurant, praised for its genuine flavors, thoughtful service, and memorable culinary journey. A must-visit for food lovers seeking authenticity.

THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO at a glance

  • Address 1322 N Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States
  • Phone +1 941-362-4220
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO: Reviews & Ratings

Matt Beno
5

Service was great food was amazing gnocchi had so much flavor would definitely recommend.

Cynthia Sabree
5

Went for dinner to celebrate my husband’s birthday and everything was exceptional! The service, the romantic atmosphere, the music playing, and the food! We loved the entire night, and they went out of their way to make my husband feel special on his birthday! Thank you, we will be back!

Total Mass Retain YES Tribute band
5

The best restaurant I've ever eaten -- that's how the 4 of us felt after our first time eating at Chef Antonio's.... so we went again the next night (lol) and felt the same!!! I'm an italian from NYC and so I always say that nothing is better than a home cooked meal... THIS WAS A HOME COOKED MEAL. You enter a house converted into an elegant dining room, we were so impressed with the authenticity and quality. The hospitality is second to none. Chef Antonio himself greeted and sat us, and we had the best service from Elena. 100% recommend - no doubt about it. The only Italian restaurant in Sarasota with 5.0 rating as of the date of my review and for incredible reasons.

Maria Carolina Ayala Montenegro
5

We went to celebrate our anniversary and We loved it... The location is like being in Europe and service is amazing. The Chef Antonio always come and greet the customers and even suggest few things. They are very open to change the plates and make you feel incredible. My husband ordered the lamb chops and they are a MUST, very tender and tasty. I ordered the clam fettucini very flavorful. Eventhough that they were closing at the end they gave us time to drink our wine. We recomend this place 100% and We are looking forward to come back pretty soon.

Joe Cirruzzo
5

So glad we finally got to try this local gem nestled in the heart of Sarasota for some home run hitting dishes. Short Rib Flat Bread, Eggplant, Lobster Bisque, Fresh Pasta with Key West Shrimp. Service was exceptional & always checking in, love the vibe of this historic home turned into an Italian culinary tour. Looking forward to our next visit.

Ivan Shlapakov
5

This dinner was unforgettable! We are so happy that celebrated our birthday with Chef Antonio. The food was delicious, atmosphere is amazing and so good choice of wine! Highly enjoyed and recommend to everyone!

Amber M
5

Incredible experience! The food was absolutely delicious. The short rib appetizer melts in your mouth. Please do yourself a favor and go try chef Antonio and his wife’s amazing restaurant! Will be back and will be recommending to everyone!

Elena Kochutin
5

We are fortunate to have this unique chef-centric restaurant in Sarasota. Every meal here has been amazing, and my daughter always begs to return for her favorite lobster bisque. Chef Antonio is a natural-born talent in the kitchen, with an extraordinary gift for creating dishes that feel both refined and home-cooked. I highly recommend The Reserve!

Location

  • THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO
    THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO
    1322 N Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL 34236, United States Hotline: +1 941-362-4220

Nestled in the heart of Sarasota at 1322 N Tamiami Trail, THE RESERVE RESTAURANT by CHEF ANTONIO offers an authentic Italian dining experience that feels like a warm embrace from a home kitchen. From the moment you step inside this elegant, historic house turned restaurant, the blend of old-world charm and modern culinary mastery is palpable. The cozy ambiance, enhanced by soft music and attentive service, sets the perfect backdrop for a memorable meal.

The menu is a celebration of classic Italian flavors elevated with a chef’s personal touch. Among the highlights, the Fried Green Tomatoes stand out with their crisp exterior and rich, tangy flavor—a delightful appetizer that teases the palate. The wine selection complements the dishes perfectly, enhancing every bite with a carefully curated pairing that reflects the depth and nuance of Italian viticulture.

One cannot mention THE RESERVE without praising the gnocchi, a dish that customers like Matt Beno rave about for its bold, vibrant flavors. Chef Antonio’s fresh pasta dishes, such as the clam fettucini, are equally remarkable, showcasing a delicate balance of seasonings and perfectly cooked seafood. The lamb chops, renowned for their tenderness and robust taste, also command attention and are a must-try for meat lovers.

The restaurant’s hospitality elevates the experience. Chef Antonio personally greets guests, embodying the passion and care infused into every dish. The staff’s attentiveness—highlighted repeatedly in customer reviews—ensures that each guest feels valued and well-cared-for, fostering an atmosphere that is both romantic and inviting.

The Reserve offers more than just a meal; it delivers an authentic Italian culinary journey that resonates deeply with both locals and visitors. Whether celebrating a special occasion or simply savoring a quiet night out, this Sarasota gem provides a genuine taste of Italy with every thoughtfully prepared plate and every glass of exquisite wine. It is no surprise that it holds a perfect 5.0 rating—the kind of place where you don’t just eat; you experience Italy in the heart of Florida.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards